Mfecane debates

Current debates on the mfecane we need to be aware of how, over a long period of time, certain events of the 1820s and 1830s have become objectified, fetishized even, into a. Mfecane (zulu pronunciation: [m̩fɛˈkǀaːne], [note 1] crushing), also known by the sesotho name difaqane (scattering, forced dispersal or forced migration [1]) or lifaqane, was a period of widespread chaos and warfare among indigenous ethnic communities in southern africa during the period between 1815 and about 1840. Mfecane is a term widely used by historians from the late 1960s to the late 1980s to refer to a series of wars and population movements that took place over much of southern africa from the 1810s to the 1830s.

mfecane debates Best answer: julian raymond dennis cobbing (born june 1944, london) is an english historian, and professor of history at rhodes university (grahamstown, south africa), known best for his groundbreaking research into zulu culture of the early 19th century.

The name mfecane has been used to describe a period of massive disruption, mainly after 1800, centred in eastern south africa but extending throughout much of the country it has sometimes been linked to the growth of the zulu kingdom and the reaction to it. European stereotypes, african societies and the mfecane the early part of the nineteenth century was a time of great social and political reformation in southern africa, which was later to become known as the mfecane the period was described by elizabeth eldredge as one of 'tremendous demographic. The mfecane and its effects mfecane is an nguni word which means 'crushing' and was used by the nguni to describe the violent wars that tore apart central and southern africa between 1820 and1835. The mfecane , suggests cobbing, must be seen as a myth lying at the root of a set of interlinked assumptions and distortions that have seriously twisted our understanding of the main historical processes of late 18th- and early 19th-century southern africa.

John wright (1995) ©: over the last two or three years [1992-1995] the active debates - not to say maulings and mudslingings - that took place in the late 1980s and early 1990s round the concept of the imfecane have given way to an uneasy calm. 16 untapped sources slave exports from southern and central namibia up to c 1850 jan-bart gewald this essay was written as a reaction to the attempts to prescribe the 'mfecane' as a. John omer-cooper coined the term mfecane in the zulu aftermath in 1966 mfecane= zulu word for the crushing accepted idea was that the radical political. Mfecane (zulu pronunciation: [m̩fɛˈkǀaːne], crushing), also known by the sesotho name difaqane (scattering, forced dispersal or forced migration) or lifaqane, was a period of widespread chaos and warfare among indigenous ethnic communities in southern africa during the period between 1815 and about 1840. Was the mfecane a figment of historians' imagination as julian cobbing contends how large a responsibility do shaka and the zulu people bear for the social turbulence in south-central and south-east africa in the early decades of the 19th century.

Has the mfecane a future a response to the cobbing critique created date: 20160807152618z. The mfecane, suggests cobbing, must be seen as a myth lying at the root of a set of interlinked assumptions and distortions that have seriously twisted our understanding of the main historical processes of late 18th- and early 19th-century southern africa. The debate has, however, raised important new questions, enlivened research in the area and ensured that the mfecane will continue to occupy a prominent place in the developing historiography of southern africa.

Julian raymond dennis cobbing (born june 1944, london) is an english historian, and professor of history at rhodes university (grahamstown, south africa), known best for his controversial and groundbreaking research into zulu culture of the early 19th century. The mfecane was for most of the twentieth century regarded as a historical certainty for the south african public and the apartheid government, as well as for historians here and world-wide. Mfecane debates essay julian cobbing against 'the mfecane ' has the mfecane a future in recent times historians known as africanists revived the topic of the mfecane in the early 1960s and it was well exploited and was also used to justify certain aspects of apatheid. A hotly contested issue in the debate on south africa's mfecane which enlivened the pages of this journal a decade ago was the charge that colonial historians invented the concept as part of a continuing campaign to absolve.

Mfecane debates

mfecane debates Best answer: julian raymond dennis cobbing (born june 1944, london) is an english historian, and professor of history at rhodes university (grahamstown, south africa), known best for his groundbreaking research into zulu culture of the early 19th century.

The debate over mfecane or no mfecane shows this up in stark relief the seemingly innocuous words differences of opinion used by mulder in his speech cut to the core of the issue - was the land cleared by. Mfecane debates julian cobbing against 'the mfecane' has the mfecane a future in recent times historians known as africanists revived the topic of the mfecane in the early 1960s and it was well exploited and was also used to justify certain aspects of apatheid. Julian cobbing, who initiated the debate about the mfecane in the first place the omission haunts this worthwhile book and is its most telling weakness for at least a hundred years, the mfecane. Topic - discuss the causes of the mfecane, taking into consideration the variety of historiography on this event although no one can pinpoint exactly what caused the mfecane, most believe the causes emerged at the end of the eighteenth and the start of the nineteenth.

  • Julian cobbing against 'the mfecane' has the mfecane a future in recent times historians known as africanists revived the topic of the mfecane in the early 1960s and it was well exploited and was also used to justify certain aspects of apatheid.

Mfecane 1817-1828 more destruction was caused by those whom shaka defeated, than by his own forces such was the case of the hlubi and the ngwane. Mfecane aftermath: reconstructive debates in southern african history by thomas n hamilton a guide for interpreting the mfecane's role in history was the mfecane a figment of historians' imagination as julian cobbing contends. Mfecane (isizulu, zulu pronunciation: [m̩fɛˈkǀaːne]), also known by the sesotho name difaqane or lifaqane (all meaning crushing, scattering, forced dispersal, forced migration), was a period of widespread chaos and warfare among indigenous ethnic communities in southern africa during the period between 1815 and about 1840. Was the mfecane a figment of historians' imagination as julian cobbing contends how large a responsibility do shaka and the zulu people bear for the social turbulence in south-central and south.

mfecane debates Best answer: julian raymond dennis cobbing (born june 1944, london) is an english historian, and professor of history at rhodes university (grahamstown, south africa), known best for his groundbreaking research into zulu culture of the early 19th century. mfecane debates Best answer: julian raymond dennis cobbing (born june 1944, london) is an english historian, and professor of history at rhodes university (grahamstown, south africa), known best for his groundbreaking research into zulu culture of the early 19th century.
Mfecane debates
Rated 5/5 based on 24 review

2018.